RE: Do you sometimes toss your best thoughts into the void of some obscure comment section? I know I do.

avatar

You are viewing a single comment's thread:

I think, having myself been involved for a long time with this question of a deity or a cosmic intelligence, that it is actually irrelevant.
A bit like when you eventually become a relativist because at some point you have understood that it is possible to take numerous perspectives, to practise that too, to realise that almost everything can be put in relation to each other. Once there, however, one does not have to stop there, but in the awareness that "the world can be viewed relativistically", still feel and express clarity in one's own decisions.

Only after reflecting can I say that such questions about a creator are irrelevant. Before that, it would be presumption and an imposition on the one to whom I say such things.

It's disagreement in theory, if I should put it that way. Whether or not a creator can be assumed need not change spiritual practice (though it did).

The practice can work without being too dogmatically attached to questions of belief.
A human who gives compassion to another, I don't even need to know about him whether he believes in God or not. It is enough if, in the face of a milestone event, such as the death of a relative, he takes the necessary steps to create a sense of helpfulness and togetherness. Whether believing Christians are actually better able to deal with dying and death compared to non-Christians, I don't know, but I wouldn't want to generalise.

The practice of assistance in dying, persevering with the dying, traditional acts such as laying out the deceased at home or in the chapel, where it can be taken as an occasion for relatives and friends to say their last goodbyes, the funeral feast, the open house of the family, singing and praying together are, in my view, welcome rituals and traditions that are fed by Christianity. Atheists and those who have no faith run the risk of being clumsy and awkward with such things.

Where there is a gap caused by a lack of faith or Christian (or other religious) cohesion, atheists or those who see death as an enemy are left with no answers as to what alternatives and ideas are supposed to fill the hole that apostate Christians create.

But even though I say and know all this, the fact is that I have left my own Christian tradition, cannot sing any songs melodically (which makes singing in church a poor event), nor do I remember any comforting prayers. ... I have almost completely forgotten or neglected the practice when it comes to singing and prayer, from my point of view very important aspects of Christian culture. As long as those who first dignify a service and have their recitations ready still provide their voices, they carry people like me who have forgotten and neglected such things and sit in church with embarrassed hearts, ashamed that they can no longer do it.

At the same time, I can say that the polyphony with which chants carry the congregation have been infinitely more valuable to me than any theoretical or theological conversation on the subject.
The old who could do this are increasingly dying out and the young are falling silent. I can literally watch it, every funeral shows how the rituals and traditions continue to dissolve into meaninglessness.

People don't seem to realise what a loss this actually is. It is clear to me, and my pitiful attempts to maintain meaning and ritual, for example, have shown me that no individual could revive an abandoned space, for example, because their actions and speech do not have the effect that the practice of the many has.

Can you recall or tell from the practical point of your life, if cultural aspects like I mentioned above, are still alive where you came from or where you live now?



0
0
0.000
1 comments
avatar
(Edited)

Only after reflecting can I say that such questions about a creator are irrelevant.

Only because whether there is or is not likely won't change how we act in our life. If you follow one of the human written texts then it likely would change the way you act. Whether that is good or bad is a subjective thing and also can depend a great deal on how you are convinced to act by whatever text you choose to follow.

Yet, that does not stop it from being an interesting thought experiment.

It could also be argued that there is one reason it may not be irrelevant. So many people believe it is relevant and they make decisions based upon it. It could remain irrelevant IF those decisions only impacted themselves. Once they start impacting other people who did not choose to have such impact then it becomes a relevant discussion as far as I am concerned.

I personally have no problem with people voluntarily pursuing to believe or follow such things. I only see it as an issue when they think they must push it upon other people and in some cases make laws and take actions that remove voluntary choice from other people.

I think people should lead by example not by force.

Can you recall or tell from the practical point of your life, if cultural aspects like I mentioned above, are still alive where you came from or where you live now?

The aspects of it that have been present in my life (I am 52) are still around as much as they ever were with the exception of being excised from marketing, and other institutions via force. Which I am opposed to.

It also depends a great deal where you live. Some places have removed it a great deal. Other places it remains as it was. Some places it has strengthened.

I do personally think there is a power in belief. Yet I think it is not so much due to what you choose to believe in but rather is part of the belief itself. It may be something measureable some day. That is partially why I think the healing value of prayer has been found to have some impact REGARDLESS of whom or what is being prayed to.

It to me explains why so many remotely removed religions have similar stories of "miraculous" things yet they certainly are not all practicing the same religion or praying to the same deity. That seems indicate to me that the deity does not matter so much when it comes to prayer. It is something about the act itself.

Then the thought experiment might arise. If millions of people believe in a thing and belief has some kind of energy. Where does that energy go, and what might come of it?

0
0
0.000