Collagen vs. Whey: What Are the Benefits and Drawbacks and What Should You Consider When Choosing a Supplement

in StemSocial5 months ago (edited)
man, person, running, run, recreation, military, usa, jogging, runner, lifestyle, fitness, race, competition, marathon, sports, fit, endurance, athlete, athletics, afghanistan, dedication, marines, physical exercise, persistence, outdoor recreation, human action, individual sports, ultramarathon, long distance running, Free Images In PxHere

from PxHere

Deciding on the finest protein supplement might be difficult due to the enormous number of options available on the market today. This is especially true if you're torn between collagen and whey protein, two forms of popular protein supplements that are similar in composition. Whey protein is considered to be the "grandfather" of all protein supplements because of the long list of benefits it provides. On the other hand, collagen has become extremely popular in recent years because of the long list of benefits it provides.

The best selection is ultimately determined by your aims and the benefits you intend to derive from supplemental protein. You must first understand the pros and disadvantages of collagen vs. whey, as well as how the two products compare to one another before you can make an educated decision.


Collagen, a protein found in abundance throughout the body can produce connective tissues. These proteins, according to Ella Davar, a qualified dietician and contributing writer for the mbg, are necessary for the development of bones, muscles, ligaments, joints, blood vessels, and skin, among other things. Collagen is the most abundant protein in humans, accounting for 30% of total protein in the body.
Although the body can produce collagen, our ability to do so diminishes as we age. Excessive sun exposure, sugary diets, and cigarette smoking are all examples of environmental stressors that can lead to a decrease in collagen levels. As a result of this study, collagen supplements can now be added to your regular wellness routine as an option.

The benefits of collage

In addition to its role in a wide range of tissues, collagen also contributes to a person's overall health.
It's critical to take good care of your complexion.
Collagen is a superior skin-care supplement that is widely available. The dermatologist Davar points out that collagen is not only responsible for skin's structure, but it is also responsible for the skin's elasticity and stretchiness. In contrast, as we get older, our collagen levels gradually decline, which can result in wrinkles, fine lines, and dryness of the skin. Fortunately, a scientific study of 11 studies involving more than 805 people discovered that oral collagen supplements can help to improve skin moisture and elasticity.

The condition of one's bones.
The decrease in collagen production that occurs as we get older has consequences for more than simply our skin. According to Davar, the density and strength of the bones normally decline with age. A long-term clinical study discovered that postmenopausal women who took collagen peptides on a daily basis for a year exhibited an increase in bone density after 12 months of treatment.

Muscle development.
A complete protein is one that contains all of the essential amino acids required by the organism for growth and development. Collagen does not fall within this category. Because it contains eight of those nine ingredients, it is believed to aid in muscle building when used in conjunction with a good diet and regular exercise. In reality, collagen peptides account for 36% of a person's total protein intake, which has been proven to be sufficient for meeting the body's daily amino acid requirements. A study found that males who took daily collagen supplements and engaged in strength training gained more muscle mass than men who did not supplement their diets with collagen.

The condition of the intestines.
The use of collagen supplements, in conjunction with a good diet and regular exercise, can aid in the improvement of gut health. Collagen contains glycine and glutamine, two amino acids known to have anti-inflammatory properties. Collagen has been shown to improve gut health in several studies. Intestinal cells favor glutamine as a source of energy above other carbohydrates.

Dairy-free. Collagen supplements can be made from the connective tissue of animals such as fish, cows, or chickens. Natural lactose and dairy-free products are available because they are not derived from milk. Therefore, those who are lactose intolerant or allergic to dairy should consider supplementing their meals with collagen to improve their general health.

There is no discernible taste or odor.
Collagen is less likely than whey protein powder to have a strong taste or scent than the latter. Davar points out that even unflavoured collagen is virtually odorless and easy to consume. Using this product will allow you to prepare anything from baked goods to lattes and margaritas due to its versatility.

Some of the downsides of collagen.
Collagen has some drawbacks and negative effects that people should be aware of.

To summarize, collagen does not constitute a complete protein in the traditional sense. No matter how much you dislike the taste, collagen's 18+ amino acids can still contribute to your daily protein need. The difficulty with collagen is that it does not meet all of the requirements for being considered a complete protein supplement.

Fish contains allergens. The most common food allergies are to fish and shellfish, thus if you have an allergy to collagen, you must be particularly cautious when consuming these foods. The fact that collagen supplements can be made from a number of sources means that they can also be made from marine sources. Some brands use a combination of both strategies, and these are known as hybrid brands. It is important to use caution when purchasing collagen products if you are allergic to fish or shellfish.

Stomach discomfort is a common occurrence. The consumption of collagen has been linked to gastrointestinal distress, according to anecdotal evidence. It has been reported that some collagen brands can produce an allergic reaction, but this is an extremely unusual occurrence.


When it comes to milk, whey protein is one of two proteins present: the other is casein. As a result of the process of making cheese, the watery liquid (known as whey) separates from the solid curds. Protein supplementation is possible with whey because of the high concentration of whey protein in the product.

Aspects that are beneficial to using whey

Whey has a variety of uses, and these are just a few of them.

It's a good source of lean protein. As a complete protein supplement, whey provides everything you need. There are nine necessary amino acids in whey, which cannot be synthesized by the body.

It is quickly assimilated by the body. "Whey protein is absorbed faster than other proteins," says a registered dietitian and the founder of The Dish on Nutrition. Casein, a protein in milk, is not an exception. Whey has been termed "fast protein" since it takes just one hour for 10 grams of whey protein to be absorbed into the body.

Consequently, muscle strength improves. Its high content of complete proteins and rapid absorption make whey protein a great muscle-building supplement In particular, the branched-chain amino acid leucine is rich in this diet, according to Brikho, and this is the body's key nutritional signal for starting muscle protein development. "Leucine reduces muscle soreness and tiredness," says Brikho. Athletes are increasingly turning to whey protein as their primary source of energy.

There are some drawbacks to using whey

While whey is a complete protein, it comes with a number of disadvantages.
This product has Lactose and dairy properties. Whey protein, which is made from milk, is not suggested for persons who are lactose intolerant or allergic to dairy products. Dairy, incidentally, is a typical trigger for those with food allergies. Around 68% of the world's population has some degree of lactose or gluten sensitivity, making them comparable to gluten intolerance sufferers.

Enhances Stomach ache. Weaknesses in the digestive system such as diarrhea or constipation could occur if you consume excessive amounts of whey protein because of an allergy to dairy products.
Some persons who consume whey protein may experience skin changes such as acne as a result of their diet. This could be caused by the hormones found in dairy products, but no one knows for certain. Higher IGF-1 levels may also have a comedogenic effect on the skin, increasing the likelihood of outbreaks.

The fact that whey protein has an unpleasant flavor and smell makes it a popular choice for flavoring (unsurprisingly). Given this disadvantage, artificial sweeteners and flavorings are frequently found in these products.

The majority of people prefer collagen since it is less likely to produce gastrointestinal problems and skin abnormalities. Additionally, it benefits health in a variety of various ways. When deciding between collagen and whey protein supplements, you should seek the advice of a medical professional or qualified nutritionist.

Consult your physician before to beginning a supplement program if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or using any prescription drugs. Professionals in health care can assist you in determining which supplements are right for you.



Who Am I?

I am just a beginner who lives in the Western Hemisphere of Africa with his parents. My name is James but you can notify me with @churchangel, here.😂 Being the first child, My parents, Mr. and Mrs. Onu who are just wonderful And hardworking couples. My father is an electrical engineer while my mother is a trader. They always work collaboratively just to make sure that their children don't lack the necessities. I graduated from high school in the year 2018. And My favorite subjects are physics chemistry and biology. I am going to enter the university because my goal is to study these subjects in the future and to become a respected professional in one of the fields. Between, I am an accomplished computer hardware technician. After I obtained my SSCE certificate, I took interest in learning more about computer hardware and its maintenance. I am obsessed with all tech-related and I enjoy using my skill to contribute to the exciting technological advances. I'd spend my free time learning about programming and also assisting people on how to fix any problem related to Tech! 💞*********🌹❤️Special thanks to my supporters❤️🌹********💞 At this very moment, I am unable to find a suitable words to express my gratitude over all your supports. You guys generosity never ceases to amaze me. This space has become a place of fun for me. All because of colleagues like you. Thanks for being there for me. I will always appreciate all your kindness and supports towards me and my family💕.

Your content has been voted as a part of Encouragement program. Keep up the good work!

Use Ecency daily to boost your growth on platform!

Support Ecency
Vote for new Proposal
Delegate HP and earn more

Dear @jsalvage , Thank you for your advice!

You're welcome friend 😊

You probably need to fix the title of this post

I have modified it. Thanks for the attention

Thanks for your contribution to the STEMsocial community. Feel free to join us on discord to get to know the rest of us!

Please consider delegating to the @stemsocial account (85% of the curation rewards are returned).

You may also include @stemsocial as a beneficiary of the rewards of this post to get a stronger support.