RE: Fermi Paradox – Do We Live In A Dark Forest?
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
I doubt the Dark Forest hypothesis. If alien species exist, and if they are anything like humanity, they would probably need to form an advanced voluntary society to escape the kind of political and corporate bullshit holding us back now.
0
0
0.000
I don't personally believe it either. To be honest, I don't think either of the solutions are correct on themselves, more likely each of them playing a bit of a role in the final equation.
Or, we just happen to seriously be the first civilization out there, hey someone had to be first.
What if the estimates for evolutionary probability are wrong, and we ARE the only sentient species that has existed, does exist, and will ever exist? Is that scarier, or more comforting? On the one hand, no doom from beyond the stars to destroy us. On the other, no technologically advanced aid or trade will ever come from outside.
Well, that's of course possible and certainly scary.
Maybe not looking at this in a human perspective, but how it works in the animal world. Most small creatures live their lives and try to avoid the large predators. Some creatures have adapted to keep the predators at bay. Then, on the predator level, there is only one Alpha for an area.
That's probably more of how space would be, if there wasn't a great eraser out there making sure that no civilization gets to a certain point.
Counterpoint 1: porcupines, skunks, and other critters predators leave alone.
Counterpoint 2: Humans are part of nature. We are re-learning conservation and coexistence with nature. We can use without exploiting, and generally coexist with other species.
Counterpoint to my own counterpoint: we also farm livestock, and slavery is a major part of global human history.
C1 : I mentioned that some creatures have adapted a way to keep larger predators at bay.
C2: We are the Apex Predator. Some people are alphas, some are betas. But, even looking at humans as part of the animal kingdom, we still fit in the same way as others. There are some predators we stay away from and some smaller possible prey we do not eat.
And hence, most likely we will be a delicious meal for the invading alien force.
"To serve man. It's a cookbook!"