Proof of Brain or Artificial Intelligence?/¿Prueba de Cerebro o Inteligencia Artificial?[ENG/SPA]
Source/Fuente: Photo created by/Foto creada por Rawpixel.com in/en Freepik.es
Proof of Brain or Artificial Intelligence?
Challenges for Security in the Blockchain
Robot Attack
We are in El Panal, April 2021. The user @fragozar01 moves in a great ocean of people working, sharing, having fun, conversing, connecting, and expressing their ideas, opinions, thoughts, and feelings of happiness within this great sea of enthusiastic people. He raises a banner where he warns of two places known as "Madju and Guanico", which are potentially dangerous for those who live in this sea of happiness.
¿Prueba de Cerebro o Inteligencia Artificial?
Desafíos para la seguridad en Blockchain
El Ataque del Robot
Estamos en El Panal, Abril del 2021. El usuario @fragozar01 se mueve en un gran oceano de personas que trabajan, comparten, se divierten, conversan, conectan y expresan sus ideas, opiniones, pensamientos y su sentir de felicidad dentro de este gran oceano de gente entusiasmada. Lleva como estandarte, una pancarta donde advierte de dos lugares conocidos como "Madju y Gúanico", que son potencialmente peligrosos para quienes conviven en este mar de felicidad.
A cybernetic sniper, armed with a super-specialized, modern, highly technological telescope, searches, and scans this sea of people in search of any threat to the tranquility and security of all. Suddenly, its ultra-sensitive and modern scope detects, on the banner of @fragozar01, the words "Madju and Guanico", perhaps unknown to everyone here, but which for the robot mean danger, damage, and ruin. Without mediating any kind of analysis or authorization, it shoots and destroys the banner quickly. A clean and precise job.
Un francotirador cibernético, armado con una mira superespecializada, moderna, muy tecnológica, registra y escanea este mar de gentes en busca de cualquier amenaza a la tranquilidad y seguridad de todos. De pronto, su mira ultrasensible y moderna, detecta, en la pancarta de @fragozar01, las palabras "Madju y Gúanico", quizás desconocidas para todos aquí, pero que para el robot significan peligro, daño y ruina. Sin mediar ningún tipo de análisis o autorización, dispara y destruye la pancarta rápidamente. Un trabajo limpio y preciso.
The immediate reaction following an automatic program installed in the neural connection of some of the users that inhabit this place is to kick @fragozar01 in the ass upon detecting the destroyed banner. Just kicks for the banner marked with the accurate shot of the cybernetic sniper. But what did the banner say?
La reacción inmediata a raíz de un programa automático instalado en la conexión neural de algunos de los usuarios que habitan en este lugar, es darle patadas en el trasero a @fragozar01 al detectar la pancarta destruida. Solo patadas por la pancarta marcada con el certero disparo del cibernético francotirador. Pero, ¿Qué decía la pancarta?
Failure in the Lines of Codes
This comparison, which may seem strange or hateful, I bring it up because this super-specialized robotic sniper, known as @keys-defender, commented and downvoted my post on @peakd, where I exposed two fraudulent and potentially dangerous websites. I also shared some security recommendations, to make our stay on the web somehow safer. Generally speaking, I consider myself to be playing on the same team as @keys-defender. The reaction to this comment and automatic downvote on my post was a series of automatic downvotes left by the trail followed by these users.
Falla en las Líneas de Códigos
Esta comparación, que quizás pueda parecer extraña u odiosa, la traigo a colación, debido a que este francotirador robótico, superespecializado, conocido como @keys-defender, comento y voto negativo a mi publicación hecha en @peakd, donde exponía dos sitios web fraudulentos y potencialmente peligrosos. También compartía algunas recomendaciones de seguridad, para que nuestra estadía en la web fuera de alguna manera más segura. En líneas generales, me considero que juego en el mismo equipo de @keys-defender. La reacción a este comentario y voto negativo automático en mi post, fue una serie de votos negativos automáticos dejados por el rastro seguido por estos usuarios.
Here I make myself this reflection: is it possible to create a bot that is able to read, evaluate, assess and decide whether a publication is safe or not for those of us who make life in this great Blockchain?
Wouldn't it be better to leave this responsibility to a human brain?
Aquí me hago esta reflexión: ¿se puede crear un bot que sea capaz de leer, evaluar, valorar y decidir si una publicación es segura o no para los que hacemos vida en esta gran Blockchain?
¿No sería mejor dejar esta responsabilidad a un cerebro humano?
I consider that it is not out of place to take measures to protect the users of our Blockchain from the great abundance of fraudulent and malicious sites, but this should not be done based on automatic judgments made by lines of code.
Considero que no esta demás tomar medidas para proteger a los usuarios de nuestra Blockchain de la gran abundancia de sitios fraudulentos y maliciosos, pero esto no se debería hacer con base en apreciaciones automáticas realizadas por líneas de códigos.
Consistency with the Proof of Brain is required for this activity.
Se requiere ser consecuente con la Prueba de Cerebro para esta actividad.
In the meantime, my publication was marked as a scam and continues with the negative votes cast.
Mientras, mi publicación quedo marcada como estafa y con los votos negativos emitidos.
Repairs of the Form and Fund
I appreciate the response and attention from @keys-defender and the support offered by @hive-defender in this situation. Upon further investigation, in @key-defenders apology post, he reports that the negative votes were cast for some reason that I frankly don't really understand. After performing a random review of a sample of 25 of the posts that were downvoted and that are included in the code inserted in the post of @keys.defender, in none of these 25 posts did I find a comment like the one received by my post and that I show below.
Reparaciones de la Forma y el Fondo
Agradezco la respuesta y atención de @keys-defender y el apoyo ofrecido por @hive-defender en esta situación. Luego de investigar un poco más a fondo, en la publicación de disculpas de @keys-defender, informa que los votos negativos se emitieron por alguna razón que francamente no entiendo mucho. Después de realizar una revisión aleatoria a una muestra de 25 de las publicaciones que fueron votadas negativas y que se encuentran incluidas en el código inserto en la publicación, en ninguno de estos 25 post encontré un comentario como el recibido por mi publicación y que muestro acá abajo.
This led me to develop the fictitious story at the beginning of this publication and to understand that my publication was commented and voted in this way, because of a bug in the lines of code made for the bot. Hence my recommendation that control measures should be taken. And for these situations that affect the reputation and finances of users in our Blockchain, ensure that the final analysis to negatively vote a post is performed by human brains.
Esto me llevo a desarrollar la historia ficticia del inicio de esta publicación y entender que mi publicación fue comentada y votada de esta manera, por un fallo en las líneas de código hechas para el bot. De allí mi recomendación de que se deben extremar las medidas de control. Y para estas situaciones que afecten la reputación y las finanzas de los usuarios en nuestra Blockchain, garantizar que el análisis final para votar negativamente un post, sea realizado por cerebros humanos.
I do not intend at any time to polemicize or belittle the work done by those behind @keys.defender and @hive.defender. It really is a great and meritorious effort to take care of all those who share this great Blockchain and I only hope that this incident serves as a lesson to learn and improve in these aspects,
No pretendo en ningún momento polemizar ni menospreciar el trabajo que hacen los que están detrás de @keys.defender y @hive.defender. Realmente es un gran y meritorio esfuerzo cuidar a todos los que comparten esta gran Blockchain y solo espero que este incidente sirva de lección para aprender y mejorar en estos aspectos,
This post is of my authorship and I express in it, my experiences and learnings every day in this network. All images are edited by me and correspond to various captures made on my PC and the sources are indicated in each case. I await your comments, opinions, and your favorable vote.
Este post es de mi autoria y expreso en el, mis experiencias y aprendizajes cada día en esta red. Todas las imágenes son editadas por mi y corresponden a capturas varias hechas en mi PC y se indican las fuentes en cada caso. Espero tus comentarios, opiniones y tu voto favorable.
Join me/Unete a mi Fan Base en/in Hive.Vote
 |  |
|---|---|
|
Si Te Gusto el Contenido
Puedes Donar Bitcoin a esta Direccion:
If You Like the Content
You can donate Bitcoin to this Address:
|
1FP9J4tJWwECH7LfcMsVEuUH7YWdtkf7CG
Images and Editing by/Imagenes y Edición por Canva
Congratulations @fragozar01! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Your next target is to reach 60 posts.
Your next target is to reach 700 upvotes.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPSupport the HiveBuzz project. Vote for our proposal!
Going to sleep, will expand my reply tomorrow.
Your case has nothing to do with the post you referenced. That post explained why some users got random downvotes (because a farmer started casting his counteracted upvotes on random posts to create chaos).
I only said I would add you to the script in that post so you would get healing upvotes.
If you think it should not be automated feel free to do it manually. I don’t have all that time (hours every day) so I rely on automation.
Your post got flagged only because its text contained the scam link. When hundreds of phishing/scam comments get quickly spread across blogs that’s effective against them. Yours was flagged in error and I asked others to heal it. You can also use @freezepeach by the way asking them to heal downvotes on their discord.
My bots also upvote everything they upvote to heal.
And sure, my code can be improved. It just requires time to do so. I do not receive funding through a proposal or running a witness node so I do that in my (little) free time.
Thank you for your comment. As I explained in the publication, I do not intend to argue with you or question your work in the sense that what you do is wrong. It is very commendable all the dedication you put into this task and if, as you say, you do it without receiving funding, it is even more praiseworthy. In fact, I always thought that you were at least managing a node.
As for automation, certainly, fighting spaming is more difficult when the volume of information increases. I think that this action is more noticeable in the comments than in the publications themselves. It occurs to me, perhaps receive a notification if a dangerous link is detected in a post, to evaluate it and then decide and automatic flagging if it is detected in the comments and replies.
I reiterate my intention: I wish that this is better, that we can have a Blockchain attached to the values that we proclaim of union and support among all of us who live here. And that what can be improved, is done for the good of all. Greetings
Understood, thanks.
Yes that could work but it’s still not a complete solution. I think it would be better off looking for some key words in the post to avoid flagging (eg. “scam” “dangerous” “steal” etc).
Some of these attackers have hundreds of stolen accounts in their hands so they could easily spam posts into popular communities in an automated way. Manually chasing all their activity would be too slow to be effective.
Regarding the comments I accidentally hit other people that mentioned a phishing link as dangerous in their comment. In that case the flag trail does not get triggered though so there’s less damage.
Will add the key word solution when I have a chance (even though it may be abused simply hiding those key words in hidden text of the post/comment).. 🤔
Gracias por venir a Curaciones Matutinas y acá dejamos nuestro pequeño apoyo a tu publicación. ¡Feliz día! @fragozar01.
Excelente historia que me aclara parte de lo ocurrido recientemente em la blockchain y digo recientemente porque hay una cuenta aparentemente fantasma dando votos negativos al parecer sin razón alguna.
Aunque tu publicación @fragozar01 responde esta pregunta más adelante, yo opino que este tipo de trabajo es un poco difícil automatizarlo y debe hacerse parte del mismo desde la responsabilidad del cerebro humano, como tu le llamas y dejar otra al o los bot, gracias por traer esta gran publicación que comienza con esa entretenida historia que atrapa.
@elcomentador es un Proyecto de Curación de Comentarios. Nuestra finalidad es recompensar aquellos comentarios que aporten valor a las publicaciones y fomentar el hábito de comentar en Hive.
Si quieres saber más sobre nuestra filosofía y cómo optar a un voto por parte de nuestra cuenta, leen nuestro post de introducción y únete a nuestro servidor de Discord donde podrás interactuar con otros comentadores, educarte sobre el arte de comentar, enterarte de iniciativas y mucho más.
Visita la etiqueta #hivecomments y vuélvete un experto.