Learning One Skill Vs Many

The debate between specialization and generalization has taken a new turn with the explosion of AI.

On a traditional level, it has always been put forth that first we should specialize and then generalize. Because deeply understanding one skill allows us to grasp its core principles and intricacies, setting the stage for broader application in related fields.

Also, specialization establishes you as an expert, attracting opportunities and recognition in your niche.

To a certain extent, this adage of specializing then generalizing still applies in certain fields. For example, in medicine, engineering or law. You just can't generalize first with these fields, specialization is always the entry point.

The irony in this age of rapid technological advancement is that while specialization seems essential in some fields, the world around us is demanding something entirely different.

Image Source

The AI Factor

This brings us to the heart of the matter: how does AI change the equation when it comes to the age-old debate of specialization vs. generalization? Is it now time to rewrite the rules altogether?

One of the main premises of skill acquisition is to increase one's market value. And the more valuable one becomes, the more they get paid.

But then, what happens when AI begins to influence the change in a skill's market value?

For instance, AI is automating tasks that previously required specialized skills, making the latter less unique and valuable.

For example, AI-powered legal research tools like Casetext can analyze vast amounts of data. Just a couple of years ago, this was a task once reserved for specialized legal researchers.

But the big game changer is that the ease of access to information and automation tools is eroding the competitive edge experts held.

Anyone can now access knowledge and tools that were once exclusive to specialists. Of course, just because we have access doesn't make us an expert but it significantly reduces the need of having or being an expert.

Besides, specialized AI assistants are becoming adept at specific tasks, making them virtual "mini-specialists" in the making.

While specialization feels the heat from AI automation, the tide is also turning for pure generalization. Ease of access to information and the rise of specialized AI assistants chip away at the value of simply having "general" knowledge.

In a way, the lines between expert and informed amateur are beginning to blur since both can access the same set of information on particular topic. the difference is in the experience of said topic, experts are more congruent than informed amateurs with regards to explanation.

As humans, being a jack of all trades is more of a myth than a reality. Our memory size is quite limited, and the more tabs we've running, the less efficient we become with tasks.

Image Source

Strategic Specialist Or Generalist?

Whether we're going breath or depth, being strategic about it is paramount. It's not about simply acquiring a specific/more skills or knowledge, but about cultivating a skillset that is both valuable and adaptable.

In practice, this means going beyond the traditional approach of skill acquisition. First, have a good foundation on critical thinking, creativity, and complex problem-solving capabilities coupled with the ability to connect seemingly disparate dots. These are skills that are difficult to automate and will remain crucial for success in the future.

Then, based on your interests, aptitudes, and career aspirations, you can choose to specialize or generalize on top of this solid foundation. This is because the "right" approach depends on your individual career goals, interests, and aspirations.

For some, deep expertise in a specific field might be the best path, especially in areas less susceptible to automation or requiring strong human judgment(e.g healthcare and social services). Others might thrive with a more generalist approach.

Either way, the future belongs to those who can learn, adapt, experiment and innovate in this rapidly evolving world.


Thanks for reading!! Share your thoughts below on the comments.

Posted Using InLeo Alpha